原书主词条 · 3 个连续词条

neither...nor...is/are

原书 PDF 第 980—981

neither...nor...is/are1

Neither Jone nor her brothers ____ a consent form for tomorrow's field trip. (A) need (B) needs (C) is needing (D) has need 请问答案(A)与(B)哪一个正确?

应牢记:在使用并列连词 or, either...orneither...nor 来连接主语时,规定语法要求按靠近原则(即根据最靠近谓语动词的词语)来确定动词的人称。

  1. Neither you, nor I, nor anyone else knows the answer. (CGEL) 无论是你, 是我, 还是其他任何人都不知道答案。

  2. Neither he nor they are wholly right. 无论他还是他们都不全对。

  3. Neither you nor he is to blame. 无论你还是他都没有过错。

  4. Either Tim or his brothers have to shovel the snow. 蒂姆或是他兄弟们必须去铲雪。

  5. Neither John nor the twins know how to spell the word "alligator." (DAI) 无论是约翰,还是那对孪生子都不知道如何拼写“alligator”(鳄鱼)这个词。

这是托福等考题经常考核的内容:

  1. Neither Russia nor the United States have been able to discover a mutually satisfactory plan for gradual disarmament. (TOEFL)

neither...nor...is/are 2^{2}

  1. Neither rain norA\frac{\text{nor}}{\text{A}} snow nor sleet keepB\frac{\text{keep}}{\text{B}} the postman fromC\frac{\text{from}}{\text{C}} delivering our letters which we so much look forwardD\frac{\text{look forward}}{\text{D}} to receiving. (TOEFL)

  2. Neither tears nor protest effect their parents' decision. (TOEFL)

  3. Neither you nor he are to blame. (CEG, p. 503)

  4. Neither the teacher nor the students were introduced to his dean. (全国研考)

这里应当指出,在非正式语体中,有时也能见到谓语动词一律使用复数的情况。这种用法已得到英语语法学家们的普遍认可:

  1. Neither he nor his wife have arrived. (CGEL) 无论是他还是他的妻子都还没有到达。

  2. Neither painting nor fighting feed men. (Raskin) 既不是绘画也不是战斗在哺育男人。

  3. Neither James nor Virginia were at home. (PEU) 詹姆斯和弗吉尼亚都没有在家。

Markdown:英语常见问题解答大词典-5.md · 1200112042PDF:第 980—981 页 · neither ... nor ... is/are

neither...nor...is/are2

1985年攻读硕士研究生入学考试英语试题中有这样一道改错题:Neither his training nor hisA\frac{\text{his}}{\text{A}} experience asB\frac{\text{as}}{\text{B}} a railway engineer qualifyC\frac{\text{qualify}}{\text{C}} him for his job.

答案为 C(要求将 qualify 改为 qualifies)。但我认为在 neither...nor...之后用动词复数 qualify 也是正确的。请看下面的实例:

  1. Neither my father nor I were there that day. [《新编英语语法》(下), p. 791] 我父亲和我那天都不在哪儿。

  2. Neither he nor his wife have the faintest idea of what lies beyond it. (同上) 他和他妻子对此外的事情所知甚少。

neither...nor...is/are 1^{1}

Markdown:英语常见问题解答大词典-5.md · 1204312054PDF:第 980—981 页 · neither ... nor ... is/are

neither...nor...is/are3

(1)Neither he nor I ____ for the plan. A. were B. is C. are D. am

《海淀名题·高中英语语法完全解题》(东北师大出版社, p. 190) 给的答案是 D, 并指出, 谓语动词必须与最靠近它的主语保持一致。

(2) ____ you or he the teacher of English? Neither my sister nor my mother ____ present at the meeting. A. Are; is B. Is; are C. Are; are D. Is; is

《新高考·英语必考语法精析》(商务印书馆国际有限公司, p. 330) 给的答案是 A, 并指出, 动词与靠近的主语一致。

我的问题是:试题(1)能否选AC?试题(2)能否选C?

此类试题虽然经常出现,但是早已过时,因为它们大大偏离了现代英语的实际用法。让学生抠此类试题不仅会浪费他们宝贵的时间,而且会妨碍他们学到真正的英语。LDCE(1987年版,p.475)明确指出:

neither . . . nor 通常接代词的复数和动词的复数形式,但在正式语体中除外。”

CEED(1995 年版, p. 662) 也指出:

“当第三人称和第一人称或者第二人称和第三人称配合使用时,采用复数动词听起来更好一些。”

请分析下面的实例:

  1. Neither she nor her partner was (or were) free to come. 她和她的伙伴都没空来。

  2. Neither my father nor I were there. 我父亲和我都不在那里。

  3. Neither he nor his wife have arrived. 无论是他还是他的妻子都还没有到达。

  4. Neither painting nor fighting feed men. 既不是绘画也不是战斗在哺育男人。

Markdown:英语常见问题解答大词典-5.md · 1205512088PDF:第 980—981 页 · neither ... nor ... is/are