原书主词条 · 10 个连续词条

but

原书 PDF 第 280—283

but2

许多有关英语写作和英语修辞的书都说 but 不可用在句首。但是,我在英语原著中却不止一次地读到以 but 开头的句子。

有些语言学家早已指出,这个禁止在语法上或逻辑上都是没有充足理由的,并论证说,but位于句首的用法贯穿于语言发展的每一个阶段,下面是一些实例:

  1. But I'm not going to argue with you tonight. (Priestley) 但我今天晚上不打算和你吵架。

  2. You may think I am exaggerating. But I can assure you that these figures are correct. (DEU) 你也许认为我在夸大,但我可以向你保证这些数字是准确的。

  3. There will still be difficulties. But they can be overcome. (Mis) 还将会有困难。但是能够克服。

  4. George was quite prepared to join us. But he was not prepared to pay his share. (RWRT) 乔治完全做好加入我们团体的准备。但是他不准备付那份费用。

Markdown:英语常见问题解答大词典-2.md · 56985711PDF:第 280 页 · but 2-4

but3

(1)Not a man but had tears in his eyes. (LDCE)

(2) Never a month passes but she writes to her old parents. (OSD)

(3) It never rains but it pours. (Prov)

(4) No man is too old but he may learn. (ALD)

请问上面四句中的 but 的意义和用法是否相同?

句(1)和句(4)中的 but 虽然都具有否定意义,但是它们却有本质的区别。句(1)中的 but 是个关系代词(相当于 that... not, who... not),充当从句的主语(不会再有其他主语)。句(1)的意思是:没有一个人眼睛里不含着眼泪。而句(4)中的 but 是个连词,是 but that 的省略形式,它引出的从句带有结果含义。下面是类似的例子(请注意分析 but 的两种不同的用法):

  1. No task is so difficult but we can accomplish it. (Mis) 没有什么困难的任务是我们不能完成的。

  2. Nothing is so hard but (that) it becomes easy by practice. 任何难事通过练习都可以变为易事。(例1-2中的but为连词)

  3. True, it is not dull—indeed there is not a paragraph in it but sparkles with lucidity and grace... (RWRT) 确实,它并不枯燥无味——实际上其中没有一段不闪烁着清晰而优雅的光辉……

  4. There was no one but knows that. (COD) 没有人不知道这件事。

  5. There is not one of us but wishes to help you. (ALD) 我们之中没有一个人不愿意帮助你。

  6. There are very few but admire his talents. (Clark) 很少有人不敬佩他的才华。

  7. There is no rule but has exception. 没有无例外的规则(凡规则都有例外)(例3-7中的but为关系代词)。

句(2)和句(3)中的 but 的意思和用法是相同的。but 是个连词, 是 but that 的省略形式。而 but that 在语义上相当于 except thatbut (that)except that 一样, 引出的是例外分句。句(2)可译为: 她没有一个月不给她年老的双亲写信(她每个月都给年老的父母写信)。句(3)可译为: 每次下雨都是下倾盆大雨(不下则已, 下则倾盆)。为了便于理解, 亦可直译为: 除了下倾盆大雨之外, 就是总不下雨了(参见 never...but)

练习

请做下面的英语试题:

  1. There was not a single person there but who thought you were in the right. A B C D

  2. It is one of those true sayings that there is no one ____ errs. A. that B. who C. what D. but

Markdown:英语常见问题解答大词典-2.md · 57125749PDF:第 280 页 · but 2-4

but4

(参见 but that $^{1}$ , no...but)

I would have come sooner but I ____ that they were waiting.

A. haven't known B. hadn't know C. don't know D. didn't know

在一般的非真实条件句中,表示虚拟语气的谓语动词的时态是相互呼应的。例如:

If I had married her, I would have been unhappy.

要是那时我跟她结了婚的话,那我是很不幸的。

但是,上面试题的正确答案为 D(didn't know),这是为什么呢?

首先应弄清这种句型的特点:butbut that 引出的分句描述的是真实情况,but 前的分句描述的是非真实的情况(假想的情况)。but 句所描述的情况阻碍了前面的句子的情景得以发生或实现。换言之,but 句的反面意义便是一个虚拟条件(倘若不)。

  1. Franklin would gladly have spent the rest of his days in quiet study and research. But he was a very important person now, and the country needed him for public service. 富兰克林本来是会在安静的研究中愉快地度过他的后半生的,但是他当时是一个非常重要的人物,国家需要他担任公职。

  2. We would have avoided making such a mistake, but we didn't follow his sound advice. 我们本来可以不犯这样的错误,只是我们没有接受他的忠告(倘若我们接受了他的忠告,我们本来是可以避免这样的错误的)。

  3. They might have left earlier, but the car wasn't ready. 要是汽车准备好了的话,他们本可能早点儿离开的。

  4. I would have written before but I have been ill. (Yeats) 要不是我病了的话,我会在此之前写信的。

由这些实例可以很容易理解,为什么在 but 句中使用陈述语气,而在它前面的句子里使用虚拟语气了。

请做下面的试题:

  1. I ____ abroad but I had no money. A. would go B. would have gone C. would be going D. will have gone

  2. What happened to the flower I gave you?” “The flower ____ well, but I did not water it.A. would grow B. might grow C. would have grown D. should have grown (参见 but that 2^{2} )

Markdown:英语常见问题解答大词典-2.md · 57505788PDF:第 280 页 · but 2-4

but5

I didn't help him. I would have ____ I didn't have the money.

A. or B. but C. otherwise D. still [全国职称英语等级统一考试试题, 综合与人文类 (A 级), 1999, I - 1]

标准答案为 B(but)。但是,我对于此种用法的 but 不甚了,请给予分析。

见上条, subjunctive mood 9^{9} I 项。

Markdown:英语常见问题解答大词典-2.md · 57895798PDF:第 281 页 · but 5-6

but6

Hewas but a fly by an eagle.

[原译]而是像一只鹰那样飞行。(《英汉辞海》, p. 677)

上面的译文是否正确?

译者没有注意到副词 but 在这里的意义和用法,显然也是误译的一个原因。but 在这里的含义是“只不过”“仅仅”(only)。例如:

  1. He is but a child. (Eckersley) 他只不过是个孩子。

  2. Deeds are fruits, words are but leaves. (Prov) 行动是果实,言语只不过是叶子。

  3. My friends, I realize I am but a guest on this journey, and I am honoured as such. (Dan Brown, The Da Vinci Code) 朋友们,我发现在这旅途上我只是一位客人,我为此深感荣幸。(《达·芬奇密码》)

[试译]他与雄鹰相比,只不过是一只苍蝇而已。

Markdown:英语常见问题解答大词典-2.md · 57995816PDF:第 281 页 · but 5-6

but7

the last but one

Smith was the last but one to arrive.

请问句中的 but 是什么词, 具有什么含义?

这里的 but 是介词,含义是“除……之外”。常见的搭配有 (the) first but one(第二),

(the) last but one(倒数第二),(the) last but two(倒数第三),(the) next but one(隔一个):

  1. His house is the last but one in the street. (LDCE) 他的房子在这条街上是倒数第二栋。
Markdown:英语常见问题解答大词典-2.md · 58175830PDF:第 282 页 · but 7-11

but8

2. Take the next turning but one on your left. (ALD) 请在你左方的第二个转弯处转弯。

说明
  1. Take the next turning but one on your left. (ALD) 请在你左方的第二个转弯处转弯。

but do/but doing

下面是《大学英语·精读》第一册的课后练习题:

With language, we can do all the following but ____

A. producing good health. B. communicating to other people.

C. passing ideas from group to group. D. turning experiences into symbols.

下面是《大学英语》1997年第8期(p.7)对上面的试题提出的否定意见:

“此题 but 后的四个选择项全部用了动名词短语;这可能是因为编者认为只要是介词,其后的动词就要用其动名词形式。殊不知,偏偏有个例外:

Prepositions can also be followed by verbs but, except after but and except, the verb must be in the gerund form;

The only exceptions to the gerund rule are except and but (preposition), which take the bare infinitive.

这就是说介词中只有 exceptbut 后接的是没有 to 的动词不定式, 而不是像其它介词那样接动名词。

I've done everything you wanted except (or but) make the beds.

所以,上列四个选择的动名词都须改为没有 to 的不定式。”

我的问题是: but 之后绝不可接动名词, 而只能接不带 to 的动词不定式吗?

由于 but 究竟是连词还是介词,常常难以断定,所以其后既可以接动词不定式,也可以接动名词。CGEL 书中的例句可以证明这一点:

He does everything in the house {exceptbut}{putputting}\left\{ \begin{array}{l} \text{except} \\ \text{but} \end{array} \right\} \left\{ \begin{array}{l} \text{put} \\ \text{putting} \end{array} \right\} the children to bed. (CGEL, § 9.58)

除了安排孩子们上床睡觉之外,他在家里什么事都干。

[附注]but接动名词的结构用得较少。

Markdown:英语常见问题解答大词典-2.md · 58315868PDF:第 282 页 · but 7-11

but9

but do/but to do 见 except do/except to do, to $^{2}$ , but $^{11}$

说明

but do/but to doexcept do/except to do, to 2^{2} , but 11^{11} but me/Inobody but

Markdown:英语常见问题解答大词典-2.md · 58695874PDF:第 282 页 · but 7-11

but12

can but, cannot but 见 can $^{5}$

Markdown:英语常见问题解答大词典-2.md · 59015904PDF:第 283 页 · but 12-13

but13

but/except 见 except/but

Markdown:英语常见问题解答大词典-2.md · 59055908PDF:第 283 页 · but 12-13